Why Cutting Everything You Love From Your Diet Won’t Work—And What to Do Instead

When it comes to health and fitness, most advice seems to revolve around cutting things out: less sugar, fewer carbs, no desserts, no fun. But what if we flipped the script? What if the focus wasn’t on what you can’t have, but on what you can add to your life to feel stronger, healthier, and more balanced?

Welcome to the “addition over subtraction” mindset. It’s all about embracing a positive approach to food, exercise, and wellness. Let’s dive into why this perspective works and how you can start using it today.

1. Add Nutrient-Dense Foods Instead of Cutting Out “Bad” Ones

First things first: food isn’t “good” or “bad.” A donut isn’t evil, and kale doesn’t come with a halo. Instead of obsessing over cutting out foods you love, focus on adding nutrient-dense options to your meals.

Why It Works: When you fill your plate with fruits, vegetables, lean proteins, and whole grains, there’s naturally less room for less-nutritious choices—without feeling deprived.

How to Start Adding:

• Include a handful of spinach in your morning smoothie or scrambled eggs.

• Snack on fresh fruit instead of reaching for chips.

• Add roasted veggies to your pasta or pizza (yes, pizza!).

2. Celebrate Balance (Yes, Treats Are Part of the Plan)

Let’s be clear: eating nutrient-dense foods doesn’t mean cutting out your favorite treats. Balance is key. Incorporating your favorite indulgences in moderation not only makes your approach sustainable but also removes the guilt that often leads to overindulging.

Why It Works: Allowing treats helps you build a healthy relationship with food and reduces the “forbidden fruit” effect.

How to Start Adding Balance:

• Enjoy a small dessert after dinner when you’re craving it, and savor every bite.

• Pair indulgent meals with something nutrient-dense, like a burger with a side salad.

• Practice the “80/20 rule”: eat nutrient-rich foods 80% of the time and save 20% for treats.

Pro Tip: Remember, one cookie won’t derail your health journey. It’s what you do consistently that matters most.

3. Apply the Addition Mindset to Exercise

The “addition” concept doesn’t just apply to food—it works wonders for fitness, too. Instead of focusing on the exercises you hate or can’t do, think about the activities you enjoy and how you can add more movement into your day.

Why It Works: When exercise feels like a punishment, it’s hard to stay consistent. But when it’s something you look forward to, it becomes a habit.

How to Start Adding Movement:

• Love dancing? Turn up your favorite playlist and dance around the living room for 10 minutes.

• Enjoy nature? Add a brisk walk or hike to your routine.

• Hate the gym? Try a home workout, yoga, or a recreational sport you love.

4. Focus on What You Gain, Not What You Lose

The “subtraction” mindset often focuses on what you’re losing—calories, weight, inches. The “addition” mindset shifts your focus to what you’re gaining: energy, strength, confidence, and better overall health.

Why It Works: This positive framing makes the process feel empowering and rewarding rather than restrictive.

How to Start Focusing on Gains:

• Track non-scale victories like improved sleep, increased energy, or lifting heavier weights.

• Celebrate small milestones, like completing a new workout or choosing a healthier meal.

• Reflect on how these changes make you feel, both mentally and physically.

Pro Tip: Your health journey isn’t just about what you lose—it’s about what you gain along the way.

5. Make the Process Enjoyable and Sustainable

The best health and fitness plan is the one you can stick with long-term. By focusing on addition rather than subtraction, you create a positive, enjoyable approach that feels sustainable.

Why It Works: When you enjoy the process, you’re more likely to stay consistent and see lasting results.

How to Make It Fun:

• Experiment with new recipes and find nutrient-dense meals you genuinely love.

• Mix up your workouts to keep things fresh—try a dance class, a new fitness app, or a group hike.

• Turn healthy habits into family or friend activities to make them more social.

6. The Big Picture: Building a Positive Lifestyle

The “addition over subtraction” mindset isn’t about quick fixes or temporary diets—it’s about creating a lifestyle that feels good, works for you, and supports your long-term goals.

What It Means:

• It’s not about cutting out the foods you love—it’s about adding foods that nourish you.

• It’s not about punishing your body with grueling workouts—it’s about finding movement that makes you feel strong and happy.

• It’s not about being perfect—it’s about being consistent.

Pro Tip: Every small step you take toward adding healthy choices is a step toward a better, more balanced lifestyle.

The Bottom Line

Health and fitness don’t have to be about deprivation or sacrifice. By focusing on addition instead of subtraction, you can create a positive, enjoyable, and sustainable approach to your goals.

So, go ahead: add that extra serving of veggies, try that fun new workout, and savor that slice of cake guilt-free. When you focus on what you’re gaining—not what you’re giving up—you’ll find that health and happiness can coexist beautifully.

Download Free Interactive Monthly Workout Calendar